Editorials Blast Speaker Ryan's 'Flimsy Excuse for Inaction' on Immigration Reform
"The House of Representatives will not vote on comprehensive immigration legislation as long as President Obama is in office" [11/4]
Speaker Ryan is offering up the same disingenuous arguments as Speaker Boehner because nothing has changed: radical, anti-immigrant Members of the House GOP still control the gavel. In the very same paper where Speaker Ryan penned his Op-Ed, the USA TODAY Editorial Board blasts the new Speaker for his total abdication of his responsibility to the American people:
USA TODAY Editorial Board: Paul Ryan walls off immigration reform
…Congress could take a giant step toward resolving this mess. But, as new speaker of the House Paul Ryan made clear in his first round of Sunday talk show interviews, that's not going to happen, certainly not during Barack Obama's presidency.
Ryan said the House has no intention of considering immigration overhaul as long as Obama is in office. His flimsy excuse for inaction? That Republicans can't trust a president who used executive orders to make broad changes to immigration policy, instead of working through the legislative process.
…Obama acted only because the GOP-controlled House refused to even take up immigration reform after the Senate passed a bipartisan measure, 68-32, that would combine tighter border enforcement with an arduous pathway to citizenship for undocumented workers…
Ryan apparently felt he couldn't get elected speaker unless he made a pact with the House's rejectionist wing. And when one of your party's leading presidential candidates offers impractical fixes and calls Mexican immigrants "rapists," it would take unusual courage to stand up for a better way.
No matter what excuse Ryan gives, though, this is the view that he enables by putting immigration reform off-limits. It is unworthy of someone who claims to want to lead one of the government's most dysfunctional institutions in a new and better direction.
That sentiment – that Speaker Ryan has sold out millions to appease a few dozen radical Republicans – is being echoed by editorials across the country:
Miami Herald: Reform still stuck in GOP House
It's no surprise that U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan, the new speaker of the House, declared that immigration reform is dead during the current Congress. The tea-party faction of his Republican caucus would tear him apart politically if he dared to bring a genuine reform measure to the floor.
But it's important to set the record straight because the issue is far too important to the future of the country, and it's not going away just because one party can't deal with it: Blaming President Obama for the problem, as Mr. Ryan did this week, is a gross distortion of the record…
?The Senate actually passed a bipartisan immigration reform bill after Mr. Obama's 2012 re-election with 14 Republican votes.
? When that bill moved to the House, Mr. Obama generally stayed quiet in order to give then-Speaker John Boehner room for political maneuver. Yet even with that, House Republicans refused to go along…
Now the Republicans are stuck with the line that Mr. Obama can't be trusted. But that doesn't make it true. It doesn't square with the record…The speaker's story that the president can't be trusted may play well in his caucus, but it won't play at all with the voters…
Sacramento Bee: Paul Ryan caves on immigration as he becomes House speaker
House Speaker Paul Ryan's weekend pronouncement that a much-needed immigration overhaul won't happen provides a sad commentary on the start of his speakership.
In other words, one of his first acts of leadership was to cede immigration policy to the likes of Rep. Mo Brooks, an Alabama Republican and member of the so-called Freedom Caucus. Brooks, who has held elective office off and on since 1982, won his congressional seat in the Republican wave of 2010, and makes illegal immigration one of his signature issues.
In 2011, he declared he would "do anything short of shooting" illegal immigrants to make them stop "taking jobs from American citizens." In 2014, he accused Democrats of launching a "war on whites."
…Brooks exacted the pledge from Ryan, writing in a letter he submitted to the congressional record that the Wisconsin Republican agreed to "not allow any immigration bill to reach the House floor" unless a majority of House Republicans support it…
Now, there will be no immigration bill, not in an election year, not when the president is a lame duck, and definitely not when all an ambitious politician needs to become speaker is to let some of his supposed convictions go.
Minneapolis Star Tribune: Speaker Ryan plays politics with immigration reform
Making his first rounds of Sunday talk shows over the weekend, newly anointed U.S. House Speaker Paul Ryan dropped this little bombshell: There will be no movement on immigration in the coming year because he finds President Obama "untrustworthy" on the issue.
This stands in stark contrast to Ryan's statements just five days ago, when he said, upon assuming his new role, that Republicans and Democrats should "pray for a deeper understanding" of one another and work together as representatives of the American people rather than as partisans…
Little mention has been made of the fact that President Ronald Reagan used his executive powers to protect minor children from deportation in 1987…Similarly, President George H.W. Bush in 1990 granted deportation protection to 1.5 million spouses and children of those legalized under amnesty. His executive order covered about 40 percent of the then-undocumented population. Obama's executive order covers about the same percentage, which today is just under 5 million. No Republicans accused Reagan or Bush of overstepping their authority or declared either untrustworthy.
A cynical person might believe that Ryan's ultimate goal is to preserve immigration as a galvanizing election issue while neatly sidestepping any messy negotiations that might bring his side in line for rebukes from the right.